Wonderette Smurfette vs. Empath Smurf

Wonderette Smurfette vs. Empath Smurf was a court case that was brought before Papa Smurf as the presiding judge in this case in the EMPATH: The Luckiest Smurf story "The Other Smurfette". The plaintiff in this case was Wonderette Smurfette, who accused Empath Smurf of raping her during a night of walking alone together near the outskirts of the Smurf Village. The defendant was Empath Smurf, who presented a counter-claim that it was Wonderette Smurfette who raped him and that she was falsely charging him of raping her. The prosecutor of this case was Smurfette, who acted as Wonderette's lawyer, while the defense attorney was Polaris Psyche, who acted as Empath's lawyer and who also himself experienced the rape through the mindlink that he had with Empath, knowing that Empath was the one who was raped.

As there were no witnesses to the rape case and the only piece of evidence presented in it was Wonderette's dress, which she claimed Empath had torn when he forced himself upon her, Papa Smurf ended up believing Wonderette's claim over Empath's and had deemed Empath guilty of sexual misconduct. But before the sentencing could be passed, a third party in the case who referred to himself as Attorney Smurf presented a counter-claim that Wonderette is not who she actually claimed to be. During Attorney's questioning of Wonderette on the witness stand, it was revealed that Wonderette was actually Hogatha the witch, who had transformed herself into a female Smurf in order to infiltrate and destroy the Smurfs from within. When Wonderette was exposed for who she really was and that the court case was actually being manipulated through her magic, Papa Smurf had declared the court case a mistrial and that Empath was innocent of all charges against him.